Edward Hopper's Highland Lighthouse, North Truro 1930
A quick google and wikipedia search couldn't confirm that peninsula-phobia actually exists, but if it does I may have a slight case. I'm not afraid of being nearly surrounded by water I'm just bothered by a place that has mainly one road going in and one road going out. There is no variable for change, everything comes in from one road and I'm sure even less comes out. Florida is a good example and I never plan on traveling through there on purpose.
But when I saw that the Highland Lighthouse was located at the tip of Cape Cod I was willing to make an exception.
2009
Provincetown, Cape Cod
